ITC ruling bars importation of Epistar AlGaInP LEDs

The US International Trade Commission (ITC) has made a further ruling the patent case concerning AlGaInP-based LEDs, between Philips Lumileds and its Taiwan-based rival Epistar. The ruling follows previous determinations by the ITC – see ITC confirms Epistar infringement of Lumileds patents.

The ITC has now issued a Notice of Commission Decision stating that all of Epistar's OMA, MB, and GB LED products infringe the patent rights of Philips Lumileds. Specifically, these products were found to infringe two claims of Philips Lumileds' US patent no. 5,008,718.

The ruling also asserted that Philips Lumileds' patents no. 5,008,718, no. 5,376,580 and no. 5,502,316 are valid and enforceable, and that Epistar's OMA, MB, and GB products are not licensed under those patents. However, none of the products were found to infringe the '580 or '316 patents.

The ITC has also issued a Limited Exclusion Order, which will, if approved by the US President's office, prohibit importation into the USA of the infringing AlGaInP LEDs. Epistar says that order applies to LED chips, packaged lamps and boards primarily consisting of arrays of such packaged LEDs, but does not apply to completed downstream products that may include Epistar LEDs. Other Epistar LEDs are not affected.

The two companies have very different views on the outcome of the ITC case. Michael Holt, Philips Lumileds' CEO, said he was "satisfied" with the ITC's ruling. "Philips Lumileds will continue to enforce its intellectual property rights, and to lead the world in the development of solid-state lighting technology," he said.

Epistar's president BJ Lee was more forthright, saying that the company believes the ITC's ruling is neither factually or legally supportable. "Epistar believes that the ITC has interpreted these patents erroneously to grant exclusive rights to Lumileds to technology that it did not invent and has never used," said Lee.

Epistar plans to appeal and will ask for a stay of enforcement for the Limited Exclusion Order. The company says that its next generation MB products (PE and PN series) are already shipping and have no infringement issues related to the '718 patent. The same applies to its next generation OMA and GB products, the Phoenix series.

In addition to the ITC investigation, Philips Lumileds also has a pending action in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California in which Philips Lumileds asserts its patent rights against Epistar's OMA, MB, and GB products, seeking both damages and an injunction.

Did You Like this Article? Get All the LEDS Magazine News Delivered to Your Inbox.

Subscribe to the magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now
RELATED ARTICLES

Cree brings legal action against LED lamp manufacturer Feit

The LED manufacturer and SSL lamp manufacturer claims that Feit has improperly used Cree intellectual property and that th...

LED phosphor news: UCSB studies optimization, Cree licenses remote technology

Researchers at the University of California at Santa Barbara say that they have discovered how to formulate LED phosphors ...

LED business news: FTC vs Lights of America; Intematix, Veeco, Synos (Updated)

The Federal Trade Commision won a federal court ruling against Lights of America, while Intematix announces new green alum...

LED business news: Nichia, Everlight, Osram, Dominant, Cree, Silver Spring, and Sunrise

Nichia wins round in LED IP battle with Everlight, Dominant says it settled an IP skirmish with Osram, Cree introduces a 9...

LED optics intellectual property can foreshadow winners in SSL products (MAGAZINE)

A look back at patent activity in the LED optics space could have predicted some of the strong players in SSL products tod...

Everlight files amended LED patent complaint against Nichia

After an earlier complaint against Nichia was rejected, Everlight has uncovered additional details to bolster its claim th...

Osram and LG settle LED patent litigation

Osram has ended its patent litigation against rival LED maker LG, and the companies will enter into a cross-licensing agre...

Philips’ LED licensing program attracts more licensees

More than 230 companies have signed up to Philips’ licensing program for its portfolio of patents related to LEDs and SSL,...

Patent News: Apple is sued over LEDs, Cooper and Cree, and more

A company in Texas is suing Apple over alleged infringement of patents that cover pulse-width modulation control of LEDs. ...

Nexxus Lighting and Philips settle patent litigation, Nexxus completes $6 million investment

Nexxus Lighting and Royal Philips Electronics have settled patent litigation brought by Philips. Philips has granted Nexxu...

Nexxus Lighting gets $6 million investment from Aston Capital

Nexxus Lighting has unveiled a $6 million investment from Aston Capital, and chief executive Robert LaPenta will become th...

Digital Lumens awarded key patent for distributed intelligence, reduces energy use by 90% in French logistics facilities (Updated)

Digital Lumens has been issued a US patent for wireless control of smart LED fixtures and it will install the system in tw...

Osram settles with Samsung, expands China LED operations

Osram is building a new LED packaging facility in Wuxi, China and jointly announces with Samsung settlement of their world...

Albeo wins patent for integrating bare LED die directly in fixtures (Updated)

Albeo's chip-in-fixture approach holds promise of lower manufacturing costs for SSL troffers, although products are a year...

Color mixing enables high CRI and high LED efficacy

When amber LEDs are combined with phosphor-converted blue LEDs, warm white light with both high CRI and high efficacy can ...

Osram and LG receive initial judgment in LED patent case

The International Trade Commission has found that various LED products from LG infringe one of Osram’s patents.

SSL Technology Update: Patent news; Symposium on the Science and Technology of Lighting; LEDs in Germany (July 2, 2012)

In this week's technology update video, we cover patent litigation news, outdoor news from the Annual Symposium on the Sci...

Cree and SemiLEDs end LED patent litigation

Cree has prevailed in its LED patent dispute with SemiLEDs, with the latter company agreeing to an injunction preventing s...

Ruud Lighting extends LED lighting dispute with Cooper Lighting

Ruud Lighting has targeted Cooper Lighting with another patent-infringement lawsuit related to LED lighting. This extends ...

Everlight accuses Nichia of including fictitious results in LED patent text

Everlight has amended its LED patent-infringement lawsuit against Nichia, and has accused its rival of deliberately mislea...

TOPIC INDEX

CURRENT ISSUE



CONNECT WITH US

                

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

SUBMISSIONS

Have a press release or other announcement you'd like to share?

Submit Announcement

Miss a webcast? Watch it in the archives

Copyright © 2007-2015. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved.