Zhaga helps SSL luminaire makers reduce costs and supply-chain risks (MAGAZINE)

+++++

This article was published in the February 2013 issue of LEDs Magazine.

View the Table of Contents and download the PDF file of the complete February 2013 issue, or view the E-zine version in your browser.

+++++

Many companies in the lighting industry are struggling with profitability in the transition to LED-based lighting. Luminaire manufacturers are seeing their R&D costs and stock levels increasing. They are writing off increasing quantities of obsolete stock, and are facing increasing risk of quality problems in the field. Zhaga standards can help with these issues and accelerate the adoption of solid-state lighting (SSL).

I spoke with a number of lighting manufacturers who had increased their R&D spending from around 3% of sales in 2006, when they were designing luminaires with conventional light sources only, to 6% of sales last year, when 80% of the total went on developing LED luminaires.

Such a high level of R&D spending does not look sustainable for luminaire manufacturers. Costs will have to go down - not just R&D costs, but also the cost of stock, stock obsolescence, and the cost of quality. Why has the R&D cost increased so much? Partly because LEDs change faster than luminaires, and partly because it is challenging to make reliable luminaires that deliver the expected long lifetime.

Modular design helps. In a modular luminaire architecture, the LED technology is separated from the optical and mechanical parts of the luminaire. The R&D effort can then be focused on maintaining the LED module, a term that is used here loosely to define the part of the luminaire that contains the LED technology.

Most luminaire companies already use modular architectures – this is the only way to develop and maintain a broad portfolio of luminaires. While it may be obvious to separate the LED technology, the choice of make vs buy is less straightforward. Making your own PCB with LEDs is attractive, and the cost is lower than buying the equivalent off-the-shelf module. This will get you luminaires with minimum bill-of-materials (BOM) cost. On the other hand, proprietary LED modules are a burden for the R&D department, and the design and maintenance of the modules will increase your R&D cost.

Designing your own LED modules has other pitfalls. It is easy to get started, but soon you will need variants for other color temperatures, light levels and CRI values. Before you know it the R&D department has doubled its number of engineers.

Are you better off buying LED modules? Not necessarily. They are more expensive, and their integration into the luminaire still needs careful engineering to make the luminaire reliable. Furthermore, a module that is competitive today may be outdated, or even unavailable, a year from now. The dilemma seems to be whether you should reduce the R&D cost or the BOM cost. And what is the effect on your stock levels, the risk of obsolete stock, and the diversity of your luminaire product portfolio?

Zhaga offers a way out of this dilemma. By specifying the interfaces of a series of different LED modules, which Zhaga terms “LED light engines,” Zhaga makes it possible for module manufacturers to supply interchangeable LED light sources. In the context of Zhaga, two LED light engines are said to be interchangeable when the luminaire manufacturer can use either LED light engine without making any change in the design (mechanical, optical, thermal, or electrical) of the luminaire.

Luminaire manufacturers benefit from interchangeability because they can more easily switch from one supplier to another. The availability of a second-source supplier reduces risk. Not only will interchangeable LED light engines be more competitive, they are less vulnerable to supply issues, and that helps reduce stock levels and the risk of obsolescence. A subtle benefit is that interchangeable LED light engines will offer more choice in terms of CRI, CCT, lumen levels, lifetime, color stability, etc. This offers luminaire manufacturers the possibility to play with different performance/price levels in their luminaire portfolio without increasing their R&D costs.

The impact of Zhaga is already visible. For example, suppliers of linear indoor modules have started to offer products with the mechanical dimensions and fixation specified in Zhaga Book 7, even though that specification has not been published yet. Even if you choose to design and manufacture your own linear modules, it now makes sense to make them compatible with Zhaga Book 7. You may want to purchase these modules later from an external supplier.

Did You Like this Article? Get All the LEDS Magazine News Delivered to Your Inbox.

Subscribe to the magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now
RELATED NEWS & ARTICLES
Osram announces specialty packaged LEDs, previews quantum dot plans

Osram announces specialty packaged LEDs, previews quantum dot plans

Biometric identification, color projectors, and TVs with a richer color gamut are the targets of new packaged LED technology from Osram Opto Semiconductors.

Emerging applications for UV LEDs drive broad interest

Emerging applications for UV LEDs drive broad interest (MAGAZINE)

Martin Shih reports that while technology barriers remain in manufacturing UV LEDs, especially at shorter wavelengths, a number of potential high-volume applications are driving interest among packaged LED manufacturers.

Packaged LEDs news: Osram and Everlight add mid-power LEDs

Packaged LED news: Osram and Everlight add mid-power LEDs

Osram Opto Semiconductors' new Duris S 5 Color LEDs target tunable SSL products while Everlight Electronics' 5630 white packaged LEDs break the 200-lm/W efficacy level and are intended for general lighting.

Toshiba plans to exit packaged LED business as part of semiconductor business restructuring

Toshiba plans to exit packaged LED business as part of semiconductor business restructuring

After spending significant money and resources on developing GaN-on-Si LED technology, Toshiba will evidently no longer pursue the white LED business and plans to shutter the organization by the end of this year.

Color LEDs add dynamic impact in far-ranging applications

Color LEDs add dynamic impact in far-ranging applications (MAGAZINE)

Both monochromatic and phosphor-converted color LEDs are tracking near white LED performance, observes Maury Wright, and color adds impact to applications spanning façade lighting to automotive safety.

Lumileds adds 23-mm COB LED for street and high-bay lighting

Lumileds adds 23-mm COB LED for street and high-bay lighting

Delivering 15,000 lm, the Gen 2 Luxeon COB 1216 offers 40% better performance than prior components in the same 28×28-mm footprint.

Osram launches new RGBW packaged LED intended for entertainment applications

Osram launches new RGBW packaged LED intended for entertainment applications

Color-tunable stage spotlights and similar art and entertainment-focused SSL luminaires will get added punch from the new 30W Osram Ostar Stage LED family.

LG Innotek announces 3.5-mm packaged LEDs that hit 182 lm/W efficacy

LG Innotek announces 3.5-mm packaged LEDs that hit 180 lm/W efficacy (UPDATED)

A broad range of color temperatures and CRI up to 80 will places the LG Innotek H35C4 Series in direct competition for opportunities in general lighting applications such as street lights and high-bay luminaires.

Osram Opto demonstrates five-emitter packaged LED for automotive headlamps

Osram Opto demonstrates five-emitter packaged LED for automotive headlamps

Packaged LED can implement low- and high-beam headlights with 2000-lm output and each of five emitters can be driven individually for adaptive headlamp designs.

Cree upgrades color LED family to SC5 technology and adds new optic

Cree upgrades color LED family to SC5 technology and adds new optic

The low-profile primary optic and the SC5 technology platform behind the XLamp XQ-E High Intensity color LED family will serve applications such as façade lighting.

Chinese packaged LED manufacturer MLS buys stake in Kaistar Lighting

Chinese packaged LED manufacturer MLS buys stake in Kaistar Lighting

The China Electronics Company portfolio of affiliates with LED-centric technology continues to expand with the parent of Forest Lighting buying an interest in Kaistar.

Chip scale packages: Lumileds debuts new LED, Plessey integrates optics into CSP LED

Chip scale packages: Lumileds debuts new LED, Plessey integrates optics into CSP

Lumileds has announced its CSP-based FlipChip White LED intended for general illumination applications, while Plessey has developed a way to customize primary optics on a CSP LED in the manufacturing process.

Seoul Semiconductor announces CSP LEDs for general lighting

Seoul Semiconductor announces CSP LEDs for general lighting

The company's WICOP LEDs have been supplied into backlighting units for two years and now Seoul will supply the chip-scale package products for use in general SSL applications.

CSP LEDs crawl toward delivering on SSL promise

CSP LEDs crawl toward delivering on SSL promise (MAGAZINE)

Chip-scale packaging (CSP) technology has the potential to reduce LED component cost and provide SSL system-design advantages, explains Maury Wright, but the technology, borrowed from the mainstream semiconductor industry,...

Cree upgrades 4Flow LED lamp performance and life

Cree upgrades 4Flow LED lamp performance and life

New SC5 LED technology enables Cree to extend LED lamp life projection to 30,000 hours and raise CRI to 83 with the backing of a five-year warranty.

Lumileds announces high-power color LEDs with consistent focal lengths

Lumileds announces high-power color LEDs with consistent focal lengths

Monochromatic and phosphor-converted color LEDs target applications such as emergency vehicle lighting and dynamic façade illumination with tight beam and consistent focal length.

Osram launches retail-oriented COB LED to make colors pop

Osram launches retail-oriented COB LED to make colors pop

The Brilliant Color addition to the Soleriq S 19 COB LED family is targeted at high-end retail applications where shop owners prefer fully saturated colors in product displays.

Lumileds launches mid-power color packaged LEDs for niche and lighting applications

Lumileds launches mid-power color packaged LEDs for niche and lighting applications

Applications such as emergency vehicles can use the color packaged LEDs in the Luxeon 3535L line while some of the phosphor-converted and monochromatic colors can enable tunable general-lighting products.

Bridgelux to become CEC subsidiary, spin out Xenio smart lighting

Bridgelux to become CEC subsidiary, spin out Xenio smart lighting

LED maker Bridgelux will get closer ties with existing supply-chain partners after the planned acquisition by China Electronics Company, while the recently-announced, Xenio-branded, smart-lighting products will get a new c...

LEDs deliver more control and intelligence, as SSL aesthetics and performance advance (MAGAZINE)

LEDs deliver more control and intelligence, as SSL aesthetics and performance advance (MAGAZINE)

The options in networking for SSL products continue to expand, reports Roger Allan after perusing the LightFair exhibits, but the LED-based lighting industry is delivering in terms of innovative new SSL features.

TOPIC INDEX

CURRENT ISSUE



CONNECT WITH US

                

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

SUBMISSIONS

Have a press release or other announcement you'd like to share?

Submit Announcement

Miss a webcast? Watch it in the archives

Copyright © 2007-2015. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved.