California LED lamp quality specification: How does it impact the designer/specifier?

The California Energy Commission (CEC) has quietly developed a new specification entitled "Voluntary California quality LED lamp specification" that places more stringent requirements on solid-state lighting (SSL) retrofit lamps than does the EPA Energy Star lamps specification. For example, the spec requires a CRI of 90, and limits CCT to either 2700K or 3000K. And while compliance with the document is voluntary, the CEC will ensure that utilities only provide incentives or rebates for qualified lamp purchases, thereby potentially leading lighting designers and specifiers to choose more expensive products. What do you in the specifier community think about the CEC plans?

We have a longer article on our LEDs Magazine website on the new CEC specification. The plans is not to supplant Energy Star, but to add more stringent requirements in certain areas including color accuracy, product life, and lamp packaging/labeling in addition to the aforementioned CRI and CCT areas.

Like Energy Star, compliance with the CEC specification is voluntary as implied in the title. But is it really? If utility companies only incent qualified products, specifiers may end up choosing more expensive products than the one required by the application at hand.

What we'd like to hear is your opinion on the matter. Is a 90 CRI requirement simply too stringent to apply to all lamps? Do you worry about how the new specification might impact LED lamp prices – even outside of California? What about CCT? Do you serve applications where a higher-CCT cooler lamp is preferable?

I'm sure you might have other questions as well. Please respond with your thoughts. You can email mauryw@pennwell.com. Or you can add a comment here adjacent to this article.

Did You Like this Article? Get All the LEDS Magazine News Delivered to Your Inbox.

Subscribe to the magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now
RELATED NEWS & ARTICLES
SIL STRIKING POINT: Connected lighting panel will debate protocols

SIL STRIKING POINT: Connected lighting panel will debate protocols

Strategies in Light (SIL) conference co-chair and Strategies Unlimited research director PHILIP SMALLWOOD drives home that wireless standard protocols are reaching a critical decision point in this rundown of the connected...

Competing wireless standards will wed at CES, SSL may benefit

Competing wireless standards will wed at CES, SSL may benefit

Networking technology has become increasingly important in LED-based lighting, but the SSL sector is hampered by the lack of interoperable standards and the Consumer Electronics Show should see progress on that conundrum.

Understand the lighting flicker frustration

Understand the lighting flicker frustration (MAGAZINE)

Lighting control manufacturers are committed to reducing flicker, improving LED performance, and providing commercial customers with comfortable, efficient lighting and control solutions, but Ethan Biery explains that the ...

California Energy Commission proposes new regulations for LED lamps

California Energy Commission proposes new regulations for LED lamps

MR16 lamp requirements will get more strenuous although the new regulations will enable tradeoffs in efficacy relative to CRI in both small directional LED lamps and omnidirectional products including A-lamps.

DOE publishes Caliper report focused on tunable-white LED luminaires

DOE publishes Caliper report focused on tunable-white LED luminaires

Initial testing of tunable SSL products was undertaken to understand the unique requirements of characterizing such products and uncovered substantial variations in performance of eight LED luminaires.

IES publishes lighting specification for sports fields and venues

IES publishes lighting specification for sports fields and venues

IES RP-6-15 covers recommended lighting practices for recreational to professional sports fields and venues with specific guidelines for individual sports.

DesignLights Consortium launches a controls specification targeted at SSL

DesignLights Consortium launches a controls specification targeted at SSL

First draft of a controls specification is out for review and will be the basis of a qualified products list that will likely be adopted broadly by utilities and other market-transformation initiatives.

LED light quality takes bows off Broadway in the Big Apple (MAGAZINE)

LED light quality takes bows off Broadway in the Big Apple (MAGAZINE)

We've published a lot of material originating with LightFair International (LFI), which took place recently in New York City, and we have a feature on the exhibits coming next month.

Hands-on testing of popular LED T8 lamps and linear fixtures reveals promises and pitfalls (MAGAZINE)

Hands-on testing of popular LED T8 lamps and linear fixtures reveals promises and pitfalls (MAGAZINE)

Margery Conner tests affordable LED-based fluorescent alternatives, identifying the strong points in product design, vulnerabilities that may impact reliability, and suitability for applications.

Hands-on testing of popular LED T8 lamps and linear fixtures reveals promises and pitfalls (MAGAZINE)

Hands-on testing of popular LED T8 lamps and linear fixtures reveals promises and pitfalls (MAGAZINE)

Margery Conner tests affordable LED-based fluorescent alternatives, identifying the strong points in product design, vulnerabilities that may impact reliability, and suitability for applications.

EPA publishes final Energy Star Luminaires V2.0 spec with minor changes

EPA publishes final Energy Star Luminaires V2.0 spec with minor changes

The US Environmental Protection Agency has published the Energy Star Luminaires V2.0 specification one month after the final draft with only minor editorial changes in the document.

Zumtobel validates Limbic theory with LED retail lighting at Gerry Weber

Zumtobel validates Limbic theory with LED lighting at retailer Gerry Weber

SSL implementations matched to the typical personality of a shopper result in a 10% improvement in retail sales, verifying prior Limbic lighting research in the lab.

EPA publishes Energy Star Luminaires V2.0 final draft for effect June 1, 2016

EPA publishes Energy Star Luminaires V2.0 final draft for effect June 1, 2016

After addressing numerous responses to draft 2 of the Luminaires V2.0 specification, the Environmental Protection Agency has delivered a final draft of the new document that will take effect next summer.

DOE recognizes 28 NGL indoor and outdoor solid-state lighting products at LightFair 2015

DOE recognizes 28 NGL indoor and outdoor solid-state lighting products at LightFair 2015

The 2015 indoor and outdoor luminaire entries were judged based on evolving solid-state lighting technology developments, according to the NGL program’s announcement.

MaxLite delivers linear fixture designed for LED tubes

MaxLite delivers linear fixture designed for LED-based T8 tubes

Replacing a fixture can ensure that LED T8 tubes with internal AC/DC drivers meet safety requirements and carry valid UL ratings.

SSL industry waits for the right IoT standards and wireless protocols

SSL industry waits for the right IoT standards and wireless protocols (MAGAZINE)

LED-based lighting offers great potential for enabling intelligent buildings, but Tanuj Mohan, Enlighted founder and CTO, believes that we are still waiting for the right standards in critical areas such as wireless protoc...

EC and European lighting industry clash on halogen ban

EC and European lighting industry clash on halogen ban (MAGAZINE)

The European Union is headed toward a 2016 ban on halogen lamps that are more efficient than incandescent bulbs yet trail LED technology, but as Caroline Hayes reports, some in the European lighting industry hope to have t...

Philips Lighting questions lighting standards for office light levels

Philips Lighting questions proper light-level standards for office workers

Research indicates that workers of age 45 and above need more task light than the typically-recommended 500-lx levels for office applications, and Philips has developed an interactive widget allowing workers to test their ...

LEDs Magazine recognizes the SSL industry’s best at Las Vegas Sapphire Awards Gala

LEDs Magazine recognizes the SSL industry’s best at Las Vegas Sapphire Gala (MAGAZINE)

The stars, and LEDs, shone bright at the first LEDs Magazine Sapphire Awards Gala, reports Maury Wright, with recognition going to the top LED-centric enabling technologies and solid-state lighting products along with the ...

LEDs to fixtures nab finalist positions in LEDs Magazine Sapphire Awards

LEDs to fixtures nab finalist positions in LEDs Magazine Sapphire Awards (MAGAZINE)

Maury Wright reports on the 2015 LEDs Magazine Sapphire Awards program: the finalists in 13 categories representing SSL enabling technologies and finished products, as well as the judges' panel who selected them. Winners w...

TOPIC INDEX

CONNECT WITH US

                

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

UPCOMING EVENTS

  • List View

NEWSLETTERS

LEDs Magazine Newsletter

Our weekly flagship news source
SUBSCRIBE

Product Focus

Monthly newsletter
SUBSCRIBE

 

Copyright © 2007-2014. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved.