Philips Lighting changes course in LED retrofit lamp design

Philips Lighting recently launched the Philips Energy Saving LED A19 40W- and 60W-equivalent LED retrofit lamps that differ in architecture from the remote-phosphor EnduraLED/AmbientLED families and the L Prize winning lamp. The new design has no evident heat-sink fins, has a traditional white look in the off state, and offers more light output at lower power compared to prior Philips' solid-state lighting (SSL) retrofit lamps.

Philips Energy Saving LED A19 lamp
Philips Energy Saving LED A19 lamp

We covered the pertinent specifications of the 60W lamp in a story on our sister website Illumination in Focus. Here we will cover the design elements of the new SSL lamps because Philips has made major changes although hidden remote-phosphor technology remains inside the warm-white versions of the new lamps.

The current line of omnidirectional A Lamps from Philips all use a similar design that we have covered previously. The lamps are divided into three optical chambers that are separated by metal channels that encourage cooling air flow. Moreover, the lamps use readily-evident yellow or orange remote phosphor on the inside of the optics that make the lamps undesirable to some specifiers and buyers in applications such as open fixtures where the lamps are exposed in the off state.

Aesthetically pleasing

The new design is more aesthetically pleasing both due to the white look in the off state and the lack of cooling fins or air channels. Indeed, the lamps could almost pass for a traditional incandescent A-lamp, except that they maintain the unique geometric shape that Philips has used in its SSL A-lamp line.

In the past that geometry was in part used to ensure an omnidirectional light distribution. The lamps with three chambers had LEDs mounted in each chamber that faced outwards from the center axis of the lamp and angled upwards and downwards.

In the case of the new lamps, Philips maintained the geometry more because it's easily recognized as a Philips-branded product. Todd Manegold, director of LED lamps marketing at Philips Lighting, said, "That has become something of an iconic shape." He also pointed out that Philips used the same geometry in the recently-announced color-tunable Hue lamp.

The new A-19 lamps use a more traditional design with the LEDs mounted on a plane perpendicular to the center axis of the lamp, projecting light upwards into the light chamber. The optic itself must ensure that the lamps still deliver an omnidirectional distribution. And clearly the design works, because the 2700K version that Philips calls Soft White has already gained Energy Star status and Energy Star requires an omnidirectional beam distribution. The 5000K version, that Philips calls Daylight is designed to meet Energy Star guidelines, but currently Energy Star doesn’t apply to lamps in that cool-white CCT range.

Improving system efficacy

Still, the question that remains is how did Philips get more light output in the new architecture? The new 60W-equivalent lamp uses 11W, but delivers 25% more lumens than the prior 12.5W product. But generally we have learned that remote-phosphor SSL designs are more efficient – especially in warm-white CCTs (see our recent feature comparing white-LED and remote-phosphor designs).

Philips EnduraLED SSL lamp
Philips EnduraLED SSL lamp

Improving efficacy in LEDs is certainly part of the story. Manegold said that the new lamp also has the advantage of using a glass optic whereas prior lamps used plastic, and that it's "easier to deliver more light through glass."

The Soft White version, however, must deliver the light output while dealing with losses in two optics. Philips still found that remote phosphor delivers superior efficiency in delivering a warm-white CCT. So the lamps uses a remote phosphor dome between the LEDs and the outer optic.

The inner remote-phosphor optic isn't a brand new idea. Cree, for example, built an A-lamp reference design using such an architecture in January 2011 to prove that a 60W-equivalent lamp could meet Energy Star guidelines. Cree has also used the approach on laboratory demonstrations that set efficacy milestones. Manegold said that Philips has previously shipped a retrofit lamp in the so-called snow cone form factor that used an inner remote-phosphor optic.

Still, it's surprising that remote-phosphor delivers better efficiency through two optics compared to what a mix of phosphor-converted white LEDs and red or amber LEDs could deliver through a single optic. Such a mix is often used to achieve warm CCTs.

The 5000K version of the lamp relies strictly on phosphor-converted white LEDs. That product has already been sold in some Home Depot stores, while both versions should be widely available at the beginning of 2013.

Thermal design

The other big change is the lack of evident cooling fins, and clearly any reliable SSL design has to mitigate heat issues. Manegold said, "We still have to manage the thermals with a heat sink." He also added, "We've learned to better manage the thermals." And apparently the surface between the Edison base and the optic provides the required heat conduction from a hidden heat sink to the air.

Apparently the architecture of the new lamp will ultimately pervade Philips' A-lamp product line, despite the fact that the company just began shipping the 100W-equivalent lamps in the old style. Manegold said that the company would update the 75W- and 100W-equivalent lamps as LED technology advancements enable the transition.

When asked why Philips was moving to a new architecture after winning support from many customers for the remote-phosphor lamps, Manegold said "We have been focused on replicating traditional sources." He said first that meant delivering the light output and warm CCT that matched incandescent sources. And now Philips is addressing the aesthetics of the lamp.

Did You Like this Article? Get All the LEDS Magazine News Delivered to Your Inbox.

Subscribe to the magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now
RELATED NEWS & ARTICLES
Acuity, Microsoft to jointly show lighting-based IoT services for retail trade at New York confab

Acuity, Microsoft to jointly show lighting-based IoT services for retail trade at New York confab

Indoor positioning using LEDs can help stores engage and sell to brick-and-mortar customers as if they were online.

SIL STRIKING POINT: Connected lighting panel will debate protocols

SIL STRIKING POINT: Connected lighting panel will debate protocols

Strategies in Light (SIL) conference co-chair and Strategies Unlimited research director PHILIP SMALLWOOD drives home that wireless standard protocols are reaching a critical decision point in this rundown of the connected...

Competing wireless standards will wed at CES, SSL may benefit

Competing wireless standards will wed at CES, SSL may benefit

Networking technology has become increasingly important in LED-based lighting, but the SSL sector is hampered by the lack of interoperable standards and the Consumer Electronics Show should see progress on that conundrum.

LIFX cuts price - again - on color-changing LED lamp

LIFX cuts price - again - on color-changing LED lamp

Not long ago the smart lamp was $100. Now it’s set at $50.

Osram introduces dim-to-warm LED lamp for European market

Osram introduces dim-to-warm LED lamp for European market

New Glow-Dim LED technology warms to 2000K at 10% brightness.

Philips Lighting delivers LED art/light panels, adds SSL partners

Philips Lighting delivers LED art/light panels, adds SSL partners (UPDATED)

LED panels can be integrated into various designs in the built environment, while new Philips partners add colorful relationships with Hue and additional connected lighting.

SIL STRIKING POINT: Strategies in Light 2016 to feature advanced LED lighting concepts

SIL STRIKING POINT: Strategies in Light 2016 to feature advanced LED lighting concepts

Using LED lighting as a ‘building block’ for new architectural designs is a hot topic of conversation between conference co-chair BOB STEELE and EOIN BILLINGS, who will present at SIL 2016 along with partner Duncan Jackson...

Connected lighting from UK startup amBX allows dynamic illumination at London conference center

Connected lighting from UK startup amBX allows dynamic illumination at London conference center

The 'Light-Scene Engine' supports a mix of 16 million colors for variable color schemes and features wireless controls.

LED- and SSL-centric products shine in a techno-savvy gift list

LED- and SSL-centric products shine in a techno-savvy gift list (MAGAZINE)

Around the world, visions of brightly colored packages and tantalizing treats run through our minds. But in this case, Maury Wright and Carrie Meadows look toward the techies, the trend-spotters, and some folks too hip for...

Understand the lighting flicker frustration

Understand the lighting flicker frustration (MAGAZINE)

Lighting control manufacturers are committed to reducing flicker, improving LED performance, and providing commercial customers with comfortable, efficient lighting and control solutions, but Ethan Biery explains that the ...

Digital Lumens adds emergency lighting to LED luminaires and control suite

Digital Lumens adds emergency lighting to LED luminaires and control suite

Battery backup for luminaires will combine with new capabilities in the LightRules software management platform, allowing companies to install a single lighting system in industrial and warehouse settings with requisite em...

Aurora regroups, forms an Internet-connected lighting division

Aurora regroups, forms an Internet-connected lighting division

LED lamp and luminaire specialist folds its Microlights unit, readies a new “Lighting 3.0” entity to leverage Gooee IoT technology.

Smart lighting startup says LEDs could usher in much longer lamp warranties for connected lighting

Smart lighting startup says LEDs could usher in much longer lamp warranties

Connected lighting will record exact usage times, so vendors could honor warranties in hours, not the typical five years, according to Gooee, which has showed off a basket of goodies including “Bluetooth mesh” lights for r...

California Energy Commission proposes new regulations for LED lamps

California Energy Commission proposes new regulations for LED lamps

MR16 lamp requirements will get more strenuous although the new regulations will enable tradeoffs in efficacy relative to CRI in both small directional LED lamps and omnidirectional products including A-lamps.

Acuity announces tunable SSL technology, and adds CCT control to daylighting

Acuity announces tunable SSL technology, and adds CCT control to daylighting

The Mainstream Dynamic technology platform includes LED-based fixtures with warm dimming, tunable white point, and dynamic color capabilities while the LightFlex CCT system employs remote phosphor to match natural light to...

Cree and USGBC install LED troffers, teach students about SSL

Cree and USGBC install LED troffers, teach students about SSL

The multipurpose room at the North Carolina Zoo now features Cree LED-based lighting that was installed on the USGBC's Green Day of Service.

5 Things Not to Miss at Strategies in Light Europe 2015 (GALLERY)

5 Things Not to Miss at Strategies in Light Europe 2015 (GALLERY)

From added communications functions to networked lighting systems and the possibility of building a better future for human wellness with SSL, here are 5 things you’ll want to catch at the upcoming Strategies in Light Euro...

Osram gears up effort to sell lamps division

Osram gears up effort to sell lamps division (UPDATED)

China's MLS emerges as a possible suitor for Osram's lamps and LED lighting business, the second company from that country linked to a possible bid.

5 Key Technology Trends at SIL Europe (GALLERY)

5 Key Technology Trends at Strategies in Light Europe (GALLERY)

Co-located in London with LuxLive this month, Strategies in Light (SIL) Europe will bring together LED lighting supply-chain, end-user, designer, and specifier professionals for a breadth of educational content and exhibit...

LED-based lighting specialist Acuity Brands to acquire Juno Lighting from Schneider Electric

Acuity Brands to acquire Juno Lighting from Schneider Electric

Juno acquisition will expand Acuity's portfolio and add expertise in key areas such as tunable LED-based lighting products.

TOPIC INDEX

CURRENT ISSUE



CONNECT WITH US

                

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

SUBMISSIONS

Have a press release or other announcement you'd like to share?

Submit Announcement

Miss a webcast? Watch it in the archives

Copyright © 2007-2015. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved.