LFI shows LED skeptics remain and OLED still trails

While the show floor was brimming with LED-based luminaires and lamps, Lightfair International (LFI) sessions demonstrated that skepticism still lurks over solid-state lighting (SSL). OLEDs were also highlighted on the show floor, although an expert panel focused more on the roadblocks that limit the technology to decorative lighting for now.

There were numerous LED-centric sessions at LFI, but one entitled “LED performance: Myths and facts – an LED industry report card” served to remind that SSL is a relatively new technology. Indeed presenter John Curran of consulting firm LED Transformations took a skeptical approach in his session that seemed targeted at newcomers to SSL. And clearly despite the prevalence of LED technology at LFI, the technology is still new to some lighting designers, architects, building owners, and municipalities.

Component and luminaire life

Curran described known issues with LEDs in lighting such as component life and the need for thermal management. He presented a case study detailing LEDs that maintained L70 (70% of initial brightness) for 148,000 hours when the junction temperature was maintained at 55°C whereas the useful life dropped to 67,000 hours at 85°C.

Philips 75W-equivalent LED lamp
Philips 75W-equivalent LED lamp
Curran also addressed LM-80 testing and misconceptions saying, “If someone tells you LM-80 is indicative of LED life, they are wrong.” He said LM-80 only tells you how to take the measurements. He expects the TM-21 standard for predicting lumen maintenance to be more valuable saying, “TM-21 will tell you how to connect the dots.”

Not all of Curran’s comments were skeptical. He told the audience that if you buy LED products from a reputable manufacturer that other components would likely fail before the LEDs. But Curran also warned the crowd about the realities of the market discussing retrofit lamps and the consumer market. He quipped that if he bought a $40 LED bulb, “I’m going to keep the receipt for a while.” His actual point was that residential customers are far more upfront-cost conscious than commercial customers, and residential customers look for much faster payback periods preferably inside one year. That could make residential a tough market to crack.

OLED lighting potential

While LEDs have become the workhorse star of LFI, OLEDs remain the technology of untapped potential. The “Creating a vision for OLED lighting session” allowed proponents to once again discuss that potential. The session featured Acuity Brand executives Jeannine Fisher and Peter Ngai, lighting designer Patricia Glasow, James Brodrick from the US Department of Energy (DOE), and consultant Paul Burrows of Reata Research.

Acuity Kindred OLED luminaire
Acuity Kindred OLED luminaire

Acuity clearly intended to use the panel to promote its investment in OLED technology and the introduction of the Kindred and Revel OLED fixtures at LFI. Burrow did the heavy lifting in the session providing a relatively complete explanation of how OLEDs work.

Burrows acknowledged the Acuity OLED announcements saying “Before today, there was no real OLED lighting product on the market.” What he didn’t say was that Acuity won’t ship the OLED products until next year and they are likely to be below the 100-lm/W efficacy threshold that most experts believe OLEDs must reach to serve in mainstream lighting. Acuity hasn’t released full specs for the OLED fixtures, but in the OLED session Fisher argued, “60 lm/W is the entry point for being able to mainstream OLED lighting.”

Burrows was probably more candid than Acuity would have preferred in his other remarks. He said that you can easily make decorative OLED fixtures today, “but that won’t save energy.” His point was that OLEDs will have to replace ambient and task lighting for there to be a compelling energy-efficiency story.

Panel efficiency research

In his role at the DOE, Brodrick is squarely focused on energy efficiency. And he said that efficient lighting needs to address “panels rather than pixels” – thus his continued interest in OLEDs as a planar source. Indeed OLED projects won more than $4.8 million of the $14.8 million in R&D funds recently awarded by the DOE.

Burrows did note several potential OLED advantages. He said that OLEDs need simpler driver electronics than do LEDs, and with OLEDs the device efficiency is the luminaire efficiency. He also said that OLEDs will better deliver warm white light.

Still Burrows noted numerous roadblocks. He said today only 20% of the light escapes an OLED source without out coupling. There are also dispersion-pattern and substrate issues. All of the roadblocks can be overcome but for now manufacturing costs that are too high. He said cost today is $50 per square meter and that needs to drop to $20 or less.

Glasow chose to focus purely on the aesthetic advantages that OLEDs offer. She noted that the technology offers better RGB color mixing than LEDs. And she said, “OLEDs let you get rid of those heat sinks.” But clearly energy efficiency and cost will gate wider deployment, and we will wait yet another LFI cycle or more to witness clearance of those hurdles.

Did You Like this Article? Get All the LEDS Magazine News Delivered to Your Inbox.

Subscribe to the magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now
RELATED ARTICLES
OLEDWorks closes Philips Lumiblade deal and announces new OLED panels

OLEDWorks closes Philips Lumiblade deal and announces new OLED panels

OLED sale moves Philips Lighting away from the light source business while OLEDWorks gets an infusion of IP and manufactur...

LEDs deliver more control and intelligence, as SSL aesthetics and performance advance (MAGAZINE)

LEDs deliver more control and intelligence, as SSL aesthetics and performance advance (MAGAZINE)

The options in networking for SSL products continue to expand, reports Roger Allan after perusing the LightFair exhibits, ...

LED business news: Power Integrations vs. Fairchild, OLEDWorks to expand, IR LEDs

LED business news: Power Integrations vs. Fairchild, OLEDWorks to expand, IR LEDs

In LED business news, Fairchild and Power Integrations issue dueling statements regarding IP-related court activity while ...

US DOE publishes consolidated SSL research and development plan

US DOE publishes consolidated SSL research and development plan

Consolidating the Multi-Year Program Plan and SSL Manufacturing Roadmap published previously, the US Department of Energy ...

LED and SSL technologies make strong showing with Sapphire Awards scores (MAGAZINE)

LED and SSL technologies make strong showing with Sapphire scores (MAGAZINE)

As the culmination of the inaugural LEDs Magazine Sapphire Awards, Maury Wright and Carrie Meadows bring to light the entr...

DOE makes nine additional solid-state lighting core-research funding awards

DOE makes nine additional SSL core-research funding awards

Awarding nearly 10 million research dollars for efficient lighting development, the US Department of Energy tabbed nine co...

Royal Philips and OLEDWorks strike acquisition deal on OLED panels and manufacturing

Royal Philips and OLEDWorks strike acquisition deal on OLED panels and manufacturing

OLEDWorks will acquire ownership of Philips Lighting's OLED technology platform and manufacturing facility, although the d...

Strategies Unlimited tempers LED and SSL market projections but remains bullish on sectors

Strategies Unlimited tempers LED and SSL projections but remains bullish on sectors (MAGAZINE)

Analysts led off the Plenary Session on each day of Strategies in Light, reports Maury Wright, with growth projections for...

Philips hints at plans for divestiture of Lighting unit, Lumileds deal is near

Philips hints at plans for divestiture of Lighting unit, Lumileds deal is near

In advance of its annual general meeting, Royal Philips has said that Philips Lighting will likely be divested via an init...

DOE taps MicroContinuum and Pixelligent for SBIR-STTR OLED research

DOE taps MicroContinuum and Pixelligent for SBIR-STTR OLED research

Two OLED-centric projects proposed as part of the FY14 SBIR-STTR grant cycle concluded in November 2014 have been funded f...

LED business news: Philips OLEDs, Cree complaint, Once IP

LED business news: Philips OLEDs, Cree complaint, Once IP

Royal Philips will sell its OLED business separately from the planned Philips Lighting divestiture, while Cree announces I...

LEDs to fixtures nab finalist positions in LEDs Magazine Sapphire Awards

LEDs to fixtures nab finalist positions in LEDs Magazine Sapphire Awards (MAGAZINE)

Maury Wright reports on the 2015 LEDs Magazine Sapphire Awards program: the finalists in 13 categories representing SSL en...

Strategies in Light to span SSL technology and business domains

Strategies in Light to span SSL technology and business domains (MAGAZINE)

The co-located Strategies in Light and The LED Show conferences and exhibitions will provide attendees with an immersive e...

LG Chem supplies OLED lighting to Seoul National University

LG Chem supplies OLED lighting to Seoul National University

Reading lights in the KwanJeong Library are now equipped with 1100 OLED SSL panels in one of the largest deployments of th...

DOE announces four FY15 SSL research project grants in SBIR-STTR program

DOE announces four FY15 SSL research grants in SBIR-STTR program

Two phosphor-oriented projects, research focused on improving light extraction from GaN LEDs, and OLED manufacturing resea...

Acuity brings OLED lighting to consumer retail channels

Acuity brings OLED lighting to consumer retail channels

Continuing its push in OLED technology, Acuity is now supplying flush-mount, pendant, and sconce fixtures based on OLED pa...

LEDs Magazine top 20 stories of 2014: Readers like drivers and controls news and features

LEDs Magazine top 20 stories of 2014: Readers like drivers and controls news and features

Based on reader popularity, articles on controlling LEDs have become more valuable than articles on LEDs and SSL products,...

Philips delivers brighter OLED panels, drives cost down

Philips delivers brighter OLED panels, drives cost down (UPDATED)

After showing brighter OLED panels at major trade fairs this year, Philips is now delivering the Panel Brite FL300 at a co...

LEDs business news: Philips to spin out lighting; Hubbell, Totus, Axis and Pixelligent

LEDs business news: Philips to spin out lighting; Hubbell, Totus, Axis and Pixelligent

Royal Philips has decided to divide its LEDs business into separate companies, making Philips Lighting an independent orga...

DOE publishes 2014 LED and OLED manufacturing roadmap

DOE publishes 2014 LED and OLED manufacturing roadmap

LED cost is dominated by the packaging steps at the back end of the manufacturing process while the entire OLED process is...

TOPIC INDEX

CURRENT ISSUE



CONNECT WITH US

                

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

SUBMISSIONS

Have a press release or other announcement you'd like to share?

Submit Announcement

Miss a webcast? Watch it in the archives

Copyright © 2007-2015. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved.