NLPIP Specifier Report questions LEDs in street-lighting applications (updated)

A new report released by the Lighting Research Center (LRC) at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI) questions the economic viability of LED and induction street lights compared to legacy high-pressure sodium (HPS) lights.

The LRC issued the Streetlights for Collector Roads report via its National Lighting Product Information Program (NLPIP) stating that in a collector-roadway installation you would need double the LED-based solid-state-lighting (SSL) luminaires compared to HPS to meet the ANSI/IESNA RP-8-00 standard.

The NLPIP report does recognize the energy savings attributable to LED lighting, but notes that the cost of installing double the number of light poles and luminaires makes SSL too costly. “The LED and induction streetlights we tested required narrower pole spacing,” said Leora Radetsky, LRC lead research specialist, principal investigator and author of the report. “As a result, the life cycle cost per mile was dominated by the installation cost of the poles, as opposed to the initial cost of the streetlights or any potential energy or maintenance cost savings, as one may assume.”

Specifically, the SSL luminaires that the LRC tested fell short in illuminance measurements. In particular, the SSL products failed to deliver the street-side lumens that HPS lights delivered. Street-side lumens are the portion of the light spread in the quarter sphere downward and on the street side of the pole.

The LRC tested eight LED fixtures, four HPS fixtures, one induction fixture, and one Metal Halide (MH) fixture. The test included an examination of supplied photometric data and actual 360° photometric measurements that the LRC made with a calibrated mirror goniometer.

The data from the photometric files and the lab measurements was analyzed using Lighting Analysts’ AGi32 illumination engineering software to determine the maximum pole spacing for each luminaire. And the report notes that the results were closely matched based on the measured and supplied photometric data. The report states, “On average, the LED streetlights and the induction streetlight could be spaced only about one half the distance of the HPS streetlights and still meet RP-8 illuminance method criteria.”

The report does note that the results apply only to collector roadways that connect residential streets to major highways. Residential streetlight standards specify lower light levels and the report acknowledges that LED fixtures might meet residential requirements. The report is also not applicable to lighting on major highways where the fixtures are mounted much higher.

Ironically, the research also examined the mesopic vision concept where both cones and rods in the retina work together in the visual system. The report concludes that white or broad-spectrum light such as that generated by LEDs would allow the fixtures to be dimmed slightly and still provide equial levels of visual performance based on mesopic photometry.

LED proponents have argued the mesopic vision angle attempting to further the energy savings that can be achieved with SSL. But the LRC report dismisses energy savings completely given the upfront installation cost of the additional poles.

It will be interesting to watch the fallout from the report. Most LED street light trials are reporting positive results although many are in residential areas. Some are also in collector-roadway areas. At this point it’s not clear how those collector-roadway trials have reconciled RP-8 requirements. It could be that pole spacing in retrofit areas is sufficiently close that LEDs meet the RP-8 standard. Or it’s also possible that the parties responsible for trial installations have measured data that does not correlate with the LRC report.

We asked several LED street-light luminaire makers for reactions to the report. BetaLED is clearly among the leaders in the LED street light segment, and the company issued the following statement: “We have reviewed the Streetlights for Collector Roads report from LRC. Since it is an NLPIP Specifier Report, manufacturers with products included in the study were not consulted to provide insight, assistance or technical information directly to LRC researchers and investigators. With the wide range of options available from BetaLED, the choice of luminaire was not optimized for the specific application referenced in the report. If BetaLED had been given the opportunity to review or comment from a technical perspective, we believe the report would have generated different conclusions in favor of LED luminaries.“

Did You Like this Article? Get All the LEDS Magazine News Delivered to Your Inbox.

Subscribe to the magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now

Osram announces specialty packaged LEDs, previews quantum dot plans

LED- and SSL-centric products shine in a techno-savvy gift list (MAGAZINE)

Color LEDs add dynamic impact in far-ranging applications (MAGAZINE)

LED business news: Osram builds US SSL factory, strikes development deal; Digital Lumens CEO

IndyCar racing autos will sport LED-based display panels for fan information

Optimize LED-enabled DLP smart lighting via active feedback (MAGAZINE)

LEDs deliver more control and intelligence, as SSL aesthetics and performance advance (MAGAZINE)

Cree restructures LED business in face of mid-power onslaught

Warsaw National Museum preserves art while enhancing mood with tunable lighting

Strategies Unlimited tempers LED and SSL projections but remains bullish on sectors (MAGAZINE)

Osram delivers new auto-targeted packaged LEDs, and IR LEDs

GE Lighting manufactures PFS red phosphor for LED display backlight applications

Linear Technology announces DC/DC LED driver IC for 80W SSL applications

Matthew Placzek’s LED-lit sculpture 'Spirit' welcomes Children's Hospital patients

Strategies Unlimited releases preliminary data at SIL from the 2015 LED Market Report

Strategies in Light to span SSL technology and business domains (MAGAZINE)

Design LED demonstrates thin and flexible LED shelf and back lighting at LuxLive

Osram and Corning partner on fiber-based light distribution

Osram announces oval family of packaged LEDs for video wall applications

LED business news: Osram and Belkin, Lighting Science CEO, Toshiba Ultra HD LED TV







Have a press release or other announcement you'd like to share?

Submit Announcement

Miss a webcast? Watch it in the archives

Copyright © 2007-2015. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved.